The Obama administration said Friday it's extending its review
of the Keystone XL pipeline – a procedural punt that could put off a
decision until after midterms – unleashing howls of protest from both
Republicans and Democrats who want the project approved.
State Department officials cited ongoing litigation in Nebraska over the
pipeline’s route, and said more time was needed to allow for comment.
The indecision over the northern leg of TransCanada’s pipeline, which
would connect the tar sands of Alberta to oil refineries and export
facilities in Texas, has dragged on for nearly six years – and the
debate has put President Obama in a tough spot with supporters, some of
whom are pushing for the the job-creating project, and environmentalists
who are vehemently opposed.
“This delay is shameful,"Republican House Speaker John Boehner said in a statement.
"With tens of thousands of American jobs on the line and our allies in
Eastern Europe looking for energy leadership from America, it’s clear
there is little this administration isn’t willing to sacrifice for
politics. This job-creating project has cleared every environmental
hurdle and overwhelmingly passed the test of public opinion, yet it’s
been blocked for more than 2,000 days."
Boehner also alluded to the crisis in Ukraine, saying "energy security
sends signals across borders, and nations in the region hoping for
greater American energy exports will no doubt take notice of this
egregious decision."
New Hampshire Democratic Sen. Heidi Heitkamp also blasted the delay,
calling it "absolutely ridiculous," while Sen. Mary Landrieu, D-La.,
called the delay "irresponsible, unnecessary and unacceptable,"
Fox News reported.
"By making it clear that they will not move the process forward until
there is a resolution in a lawsuit in Nebraska, the administration is
sending a signal that the small minority who oppose the pipeline can tie
up the process in court forever," Landrieu said. "There are 42,000
jobs, $20 billion in economic activity and North America's energy
security at stake."
Republican Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell,
in a statement reported by Politico,
said the delay only shows "It is crystal clear that the Obama
administration is simply not serious about American energy and American
jobs."
"Here’s the single greatest shovel-ready project in America — one that
could create thousands of jobs right away — but the President simply
isn’t interested. Apparently radical activists carry more weight than
Americans desperate to get back on the job."
Nebraska Republican Rep. Lee Terry, whom Politico described as one of
the pipeline’s biggest supporters in Congress, slammed Obama's "audacity
to stand at the podium at the White House press office and lecture
Republicans in Congress about the need to make tough decisions."
"But today, he punted a tough decision in the name of political expediency.”
Alaska Sen. Lisa Murkowski, the top Republican on the Senate Energy and
Natural Resources Committee, called the delay "a stunning act of
political cowardice," Politico reported.
And North Dakota Republican Sen. John Hoeven said it was clear the president "wants to get this past the midterms."
"I'm not convinced that's a good strategy. Because people are going to see it for the political decision that it is."
The decision could also put Obama at odds with Canadian politicians who also want to see an end to delays and indecision.
Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper's office was "disappointed that
politics continue to delay a decision," his spokesman said.
Environmentalists were heartened.
Jane Kleep, director of Bold Nebraska, a progressive advocacy group,
insisted the new delay in the project "is yet more proof this project is
not permit-able and not in our national interest,"
Think Progress reported.
She said litigation before the Nebraska Supreme Court will likely not
be settled until about January 2015 – and that South Dakota’s permit
granted for the pipeline expires this June 20, which means TransCanada
would have to reapply for a state permit afterward.
The latest delay
comes just a week after a group of 11 Senate Democrats – five of them
looking to get re-elected this year – urged Obama to make up his mind by
May 31.
They included Landrieu, as well as Mark Begich of Alaska, Mark Pryor of
Arkansas, Kay Hagan of North Carolina and Mark Warner of Virginia, all
of them up for re-election. All were backers of the Keystone project.
"This decision must not drag on into the summer,” the letter urged.
Democratic Senators Heidi Heitkamp of North Dakota, Claire McCaskill of
Missouri, Joe Manchin of West Virginia, Joe Donnelly of Indiana, and Jon
Tester and John Walsh, both of Montana, also signed the plea.